In the age of on-demand streaming, offline access still matters. Whether you're heading into a no-signal zone or saving data, YouTube downloaders like Tubidy and YTMP4 continue to offer a practical solution in 2025.

But which one is better? This article compares Tubidy and YTMP4 side-by-side, analyzing their strengths, weaknesses, and the best use cases for each.

What is Tubidy?

Tubidy MP3 is a mobile-first YouTube downloader that’s best known for its MP3 conversion capabilities. Originally designed for mobile video search, it evolved into a platform allowing users to download and convert YouTube videos into MP3 and MP4.

Key Features:

• Optimized for mobile browsers
• Fast MP3/MP4 conversion
• No sign-up required
• Supports Android, iOS, and desktop

Tubidy is favored by users looking to build offline music libraries due to its speed and simplicity. However, it doesn't offer HD or 4K video options, and most files are in standard definition or lower.

Cons:

• Annoying ads and popups
• Limited video quality
• Occasional redirects

What is YTMP4?

YTMP4 is a browser-based YouTube to MP4 Converter that emphasizes high-quality video downloads, up to 1080p. It supports both MP4 (video) and MP3 (audio) formats and works seamlessly on both mobile and desktop browsers.

Key Features:

• Downloads videos in HD (up to 1080p)
• Simple and clean interface
• Compatible with Chrome, Safari, Firefox
• No software or account needed

If you’re looking to download videos in better quality, especially for playback on bigger screens, YTMP4 stands out as the superior choice.

Cons:

• Slightly slower than Tubidy on mobile
• May display redirects or fake download buttons
• No MP3 bitrate customization

Tubidy vs YTMP4: Feature Comparison

Which One Is Best for MP3 Downloads?

Tubidy takes the lead when it comes to MP3 downloads, especially for mobile users. It’s fast, requires minimal data, and doesn’t bog you down with extra steps. Just paste the link, hit download, and you’re done.

YTMP4 also supports MP3, but you don’t get options to choose bitrate, and it’s slightly more desktop-oriented.

Winner for MP3: Tubidy

Which One Is Better for MP4 Video Downloads?

If your goal is to download HD YouTube videos, YTMP4 is the better option. It supports 720p and 1080p quality, which Tubidy simply doesn't offer. Tubidy, on the other hand, limits users to low-res formats, often unsuitable for larger screens.

Winner for MP4: YTMP4

Is It Safe and Legal to Use Tubidy or YTMP4?

Both platforms operate in a legal grey area, as YouTube’s terms prohibit downloading videos without permission. That said, many users download videos for personal, non-commercial use, which is typically tolerated.

In terms of safety:

• Tubidy has more popups and potential redirects, so using an ad-blocker is essential.
• YTMP4 is generally safer but can also show misleading download buttons.

Safety Tip: Avoid clicking on anything that doesn’t look like a download link and never install external apps from these platforms.

Best Alternatives to Tubidy & YTMP4

If you're exploring more options, consider:

• Y2Mate – Similar to YTMP4 but supports more formats.
• 4K Video Downloader – Software for advanced users with 4K support.
• SnapSave.io – Great for downloading long videos and playlists.

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Use?

Use Tubidy if:

• You mostly want music or audio downloads
• You’re working on mobile
• You need a quick and simple interface

Use YTMP4 if:

• You want high-quality video downloads
• You use both desktop and mobile
• You care about video resolution and a cleaner UI

Ultimately, there’s no one-size-fits-all. Many users find it helpful to use both tools based on the task at hand.

FAQs About Tubidy and YTMP4

1. Can I use these downloaders on an iPhone?

Yes. Both work through Safari or Chrome, but iPhones may need file managers to access downloads.

2. Do I need to create an account?

No, both are completely free and do not require sign-ups.

3. Is it illegal to download YouTube videos?

It violates YouTube’s terms, but personal use is rarely prosecuted.

4. Can I use these tools on a tablet?

Yes, as long as you have a browser like Chrome or Safari.

5. How do I avoid viruses?

Never install suggested apps or extensions from these sites.

6. Which tool is best for playlists?

Neither is optimized for playlists. Use a dedicated app like 4K Video Downloader for that.